Branding

From Positioning to Visual Identity: Building Distinctive Brand Assets

Short answer: A visual identity has two jobs: express the positioning you chose, and make the brand instantly recognisable. The second job is done by distinctive brand assets: colours, shapes, characters, type, sounds and phrases that people link to your brand without reading the name. Good assets are chosen on purpose, tested for recognition, and kept consistent for years.


This is Part 6 of our series on what should happen before anyone designs a logo. We've done the thinking: - Part 1: the order (diagnosis, strategy, tactics) - Part 2: diagnosis - Part 3: segmentation - Part 4: targeting - Part 5: positioning

Now, finally, the design.

What does a visual identity actually need to do?

Most design briefs ask for a feeling: "modern", "premium", "bold". After Parts 1–5, the brief can be much sharper. The identity has two jobs:

  1. Express the positioning. Every choice of colour, type, imagery, layout and motion should say the few words you decided on in Part 5.
  2. Be recognisable. People should know it's you in a fraction of a second, on a phone screen, in a crowded feed, out of the corner of their eye.

Most identities only try to do the first job. The second is where brands quietly win or lose. Customers don't study your ads. They glance at them. If the glance doesn't register who it is, the ad worked for the category, not for you.

What are distinctive brand assets?

The term comes from research by Jenni Romaniuk at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, in her book Building Distinctive Brand Assets. A distinctive asset is anything other than the brand name that people connect with the brand.

Common types:

  • Colour, e.g. a single colour a brand uses so consistently it becomes theirs
  • Logo and symbol
  • Shape, e.g. a bottle, a pack or a graphic device
  • Character or mascot
  • Typeface
  • Tagline or phrase
  • Sound, e.g. a jingle, a sound logo or a voice
  • Style, e.g. a recognisable way of shooting photos or animating motion

Mark Ritson writes often about distinctive assets too, especially about brands that threw away assets they'd spent decades building, just because the marketing team was bored of them.

How do you know if an asset works?

Romaniuk's work measures assets on two things:

  • Fame. Of the people who buy in your category, how many link this asset to your brand?
  • Uniqueness. How few people link it to a competitor?
Low uniquenessHigh uniqueness
High fameShared with competitors: risky to rely onA strong asset: protect it
Low fameWeak: probably drop itHas potential: invest and repeat

You can test this with a simple survey. Show the target audience an asset with the brand name removed, and ask which brand it belongs to. The results are often humbling. Assets the team considers iconic are frequently recognised by far fewer people than expected.

We use lightweight checks: quick audience polls on Instagram, A/B tests on ad creative and structured feedback rounds with the client. They're not a full research study, but they catch assets that don't land before they're used everywhere.

How do you build an identity from the positioning?

Our process, step by step:

1. Audit what already exists

If the brand isn't brand new, start by finding out which existing assets people actually recognise (the fame/uniqueness test above). Never throw away a strong asset without a very good reason. Years of recognition can't be bought back quickly.

2. Turn each positioning word into design principles

This is where Part 5 pays off. Each word becomes a set of rules for the designers. In our running example (illustrative, not a real client), the positioning was Fast. Simple. Reassuring.

Positioning wordDesign principles
FastShort headlines. Motion that's quick and light. Layouts with few steps and clear next actions.
SimpleA tight palette of one main colour plus neutrals. One typeface family. Lots of space. Plain language.
ReassuringWarm, human photography. Friendly tone of voice. Rounded rather than sharp shapes. Clear pricing on every page.

3. Look at the category, then go the other way

The competitor audit from Part 2 showed what the category looks like. In many categories every brand uses the same blue, the same stock photos and the same style of type. Using the category's look makes you blend in. Your assets should be unique within the category, not just attractive.

4. Choose a small number of assets to own

Don't try to make everything distinctive. Choose two or three assets to invest in, for example a colour, a graphic shape and a way of using motion. Use them everywhere, consistently.

5. Test before launch

Test the main assets with real people from the target segment. Do they recognise them? Do they read the positioning into them, so that "fast, simple, reassuring" actually comes across? Fix what doesn't land.

6. Write the rules down

Brand guidelines exist so the assets survive. Every new campaign, social post and presentation should use them the same way, whoever makes it.

For one of our clients in the UAE, the identity drew on traditional local signs and architecture. Those references shaped the colour palette, the shapes and the typeface, so the brand feels rooted in where it comes from.

Why do so many rebrands fail?

Usually because they throw away recognition without meaning to.

Two widely reported examples: - Tropicana (2009). Tropicana's US packaging redesign removed the familiar orange-with-a-straw image. Sales reportedly fell sharply, and the company returned to the old design within months. - Gap (2010). Gap introduced a new logo and went back to the original within about a week, after a strong negative reaction.

In both cases the new design wasn't necessarily bad in itself. It just removed assets customers used to recognise the brand.

The lesson: marketers get bored of their brand assets long before customers even notice them. Consistency feels repetitive from the inside. From the outside, it's how people learn who you are.

Can a strong identity make up for weak strategy?

No. A beautiful identity built on a vague positioning is still vague, just better-looking. That's why this is Part 6, not Part 1.

The opposite is also true: a great strategy with a forgettable identity won't be noticed. Strategy decides what to say. Distinctive assets make sure people know it's you saying it. You need both.

The short version

  • A visual identity has two jobs: express the positioning, and be instantly recognisable.
  • Distinctive brand assets are colours, shapes, characters, type, sounds and phrases people link to your brand.
  • Measure assets on fame and uniqueness, and protect the strong ones.
  • Turn each positioning word into design principles.
  • Look different from your category, not just good.
  • Choose two or three assets and use them consistently, for years.
  • Never throw away recognition just because the team is bored.

In the final part, Part 7, we'll put the whole process together with a real case study from our own work.


Blue BearX is a boutique brand studio that does the thinking first and the work second. Building or rebuilding a visual identity? Brief us.


FAQ

What are distinctive brand assets? Distinctive brand assets are non-name elements, such as colours, logos, shapes, characters, typefaces, taglines and sounds, that people recognise as belonging to a specific brand.

How do you measure distinctive brand assets? Show category buyers the asset without the brand name and ask which brand it belongs to. Measure fame (how many people link it to your brand) and uniqueness (how few link it to competitors).

What is the difference between brand identity and brand positioning? Positioning is the set of ideas you want customers to associate with your brand. Brand identity is the visual and verbal system (logo, colour, type, imagery, tone) that expresses those ideas and makes the brand recognisable.

Why do rebrands fail? Rebrands often fail because they remove assets customers already recognise, or because the new design isn't based on a clear strategy. Well-known examples include Tropicana's 2009 packaging redesign and Gap's 2010 logo change, both of which were reversed.

How many distinctive assets should a brand have? Most brands should focus on building two or three strong assets and use them consistently, rather than trying to make every element distinctive.

More Insights