Strategy

How to Segment a Market (Beyond Demographics)

Short answer: Market segmentation means splitting a market into groups of customers who want different things and behave differently. The most useful segments are based on needs and behaviour, not just age, gender or income. You build them from research, check they're real and big enough to matter, and only then decide which ones to target.


This is Part 3 of our series on the work that should happen before anyone designs a logo. In Part 1 we set out the order: diagnosis, strategy, tactics. In Part 2 we covered diagnosis, the research.

Now the strategy starts. Its first step is segmentation.

What is market segmentation?

Every market is made of people who want different things, even when they buy the same product.

Two people can buy the same pair of running shoes. One is training for a marathon and cares about performance. The other wants comfortable shoes that look good with jeans. Same product, same price, completely different reasons. Speak to both of them with one message and you'll probably convince neither.

Segmentation is the work of finding these groups. It's the first part of what marketers call STP: Segmentation, Targeting, Positioning. Mark Ritson describes it as the foundation of marketing strategy. You can't choose who to focus on (targeting) or decide what to stand for (positioning) until you understand how the market divides.

Segmentation isn't a decision. It's a description of the market as it really is. The decision comes in the next step.

Why aren't demographics enough?

Demographics (age, gender, income, location) are the easiest way to split a market, which is why most companies stop there. "Our customer is a 25–40-year-old woman in a major city."

The problem is that demographics describe people, but they rarely explain why people buy. Two 35-year-olds in the same city with the same income can want completely different things from the same category.

A better approach is to segment on:

  • Needs. What problem is the customer trying to solve? What do they value most: price, speed, quality, status, convenience, reassurance?
  • Behaviour. How do they buy? How often? Through which channels? How loyal are they? How much do they spend?
  • Attitudes. How involved are they in the category? Experts or beginners? Do they enjoy the decision or just want it over with?

Demographics still matter, but later. Once you've found a needs-based segment, demographics help you describe it and reach it: which media they use, where they live, what they can afford.

How do you actually build segments?

This is where the diagnosis from Part 2 pays off. There are two broad approaches.

Approach 1: Start from the research (recommended)

Use your customer interviews to spot patterns in what people need and how they talk about the category. Turn those patterns into questions for a survey, then group respondents by how they answered.

With a big enough survey, a researcher can use statistics (cluster analysis) to find groups automatically. With a small budget, you can do a simpler version by hand: sort interview notes and survey answers into piles of people who clearly want similar things.

Either way, the segments come from the data. You don't decide them in advance.

Approach 2: Start from a hypothesis

Sometimes you have a strong reason to split the market a certain way, for example by company size in B2B, or by first-time versus repeat buyers. You pick the variable first, then use research to check whether the groups really behave differently.

This is faster, but riskier. It only finds the differences you already expected.

We start from the decision the segments need to inform: who to target, what to say or what to build. Then we gather data (customer records where they exist, and surveys or 15–30 interviews where they don't) and group people by needs and behaviour. The result is a one-page table of 3–6 named segments. Each one has its size, what defines it, how to reach it, and a recommendation: target it, serve it when the chance comes up, or ignore it.

One warning we give every client: a statistical model will always find groups, even when none really exist. If you can't describe a segment in one sentence, or it wouldn't change what you do, it isn't a real segment. With little data, sorting people by hand on one strong variable often beats a cluster model.

What does a good segment look like?

Not every group you find is useful. A good segment passes five tests:

TestQuestion to ask
DifferentDo these people really want something different from the other segments? If two segments would respond to the same message, they're one segment.
Big enoughIs the segment large or valuable enough to be worth focusing on?
MeasurableCan you estimate how many people are in it and what they spend?
ReachableCan you actually reach these people through channels you can afford?
ActionableCould you realistically build a product, message or experience that wins them?

Most markets end up with somewhere between 3 and 7 segments. Fewer than three usually means you haven't looked closely enough. More than seven usually means you're splitting hairs.

An example

This is an illustrative example, not a real client.

Picture a company selling project-management software to small businesses. Its demographic segmentation said: "companies with 10–50 employees". Interviews and a survey showed at least four very different groups inside that range:

  1. The overwhelmed founder. Running everything personally, wants something set up in an afternoon, will pay for simplicity.
  2. The process builder. An operations manager who loves systems, wants deep customisation, and compares every feature.
  3. The reluctant team. Told to use a tool by their boss, wants it to be as invisible as possible.
  4. The price shopper. Will switch for a 20% discount, low loyalty.

All four groups are "companies with 10–50 employees". Each one needs a different product emphasis, a different message and, often, a different look and feel. That's why segmentation shapes the visual identity long before anyone opens a design tool.

What about B2B?

The same principles apply, with one difference: in B2B, the "customer" is usually a group of people, such as the person who uses the product, the person who approves the budget and the person who signs the contract.

Useful B2B segmentation variables include: - Company needs, e.g. growth, cost cutting or compliance - Buying behaviour, e.g. a formal tender versus a quick purchase by a founder - Industry and size, used to describe and reach the segment, not to define it - Who decides, e.g. marketing-led or finance-led buying

Isn't segmentation outdated?

There's a well-known debate on this. Some researchers, notably Byron Sharp at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, argue that brands grow mainly by reaching everyone in the category, not by focusing on narrow segments.

Ritson's answer is what he calls "bothism": use segmentation to understand the market and choose where to focus, and make sure your brand building reaches broadly beyond those segments. The two ideas work together.

Our view: we side with Ritson on where to start and with Sharp on where to end up. Most of our clients are smaller challenger brands with limited budgets, so we pick one core segment to sharpen the message and win early traction, then widen reach once the brand is known and easy to find. Broad reach across the whole category works best for big, established brands that can afford it. For most of our clients, it's a stage to grow into, not a place to begin.

The short version

  • Segmentation describes the market. It isn't a decision.
  • Segment on needs and behaviour, and use demographics to describe and reach each segment.
  • Build segments from research, not from assumptions or invented personas.
  • Test each segment: different, big enough, measurable, reachable, actionable.
  • Expect 3–7 segments in most markets.
  • Segmentation shapes the design brief, because different segments need different signals.

In Part 4 we'll make the hard decision: targeting, meaning which of these segments to focus on, and why choosing fewer customers usually means winning more.


Blue BearX is a boutique brand studio that does the thinking first and the work second. Not sure who your brand is really for? Brief us.


FAQ

What is market segmentation? Market segmentation is the process of dividing a market into groups of customers who have different needs and behave differently, so a brand can understand the market and decide where to focus.

What are the main types of market segmentation? The common types are demographic (age, income, gender), geographic (location), behavioural (how and how often people buy) and psychographic or needs-based (what people value and why they buy). Needs-based and behavioural segmentation are usually the most useful for brand strategy.

What is STP in marketing? STP stands for Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning: split the market into groups, choose which groups to focus on, then decide what the brand should stand for in those customers' minds.

How many segments should a market have? Most markets divide into 3–7 meaningful segments. Each one should be clearly different, big enough to matter, measurable, reachable and actionable.

What's the difference between segmentation and personas? Segments come from research and describe real groups of customers, including their size. Personas are often invented in a workshop to describe an imagined typical customer. Personas can be useful for communicating a segment, but only after the segment has been found in real data.

More Insights