Strategy

Why We Never Start a Brand With the Logo

Short answer: A logo can only express a strategy. It can't replace one. If you design the identity before you know who the brand is for, what it competes against and what it should stand for, you're decorating a guess. That's why every project at Blue BearX starts with diagnosis and strategy, and only then gets to design.


Almost every brand conversation we have starts the same way.

"We need a new logo."

Sometimes it's a new website, a refreshed look or "something that feels more premium". The request is always visual, and that makes sense: the visual identity is the part of a brand you can see, so it's the part people assume is broken.

It usually isn't.

A recent client is a good example. They came to us asking for a new logo, convinced that was what was holding the brand back. Once we started the diagnosis, it was clear the real problem was positioning: the brand didn't clearly stand for anything, so no logo, however good, could have told customers why to choose it. The work had to start there.

What's wrong with starting with the logo?

Starting with the logo means making the most visible decision first, with the least information.

A visual identity is a set of choices: colour, type, shape, tone, motion. Every one of those choices should answer a question. Who are we trying to reach? What do they already believe about this category? What do we want them to remember about us?

If those questions haven't been answered, the designer answers them anyway, just without realising it. The result is usually one of three things:

  • The category average. It looks like every competitor, because that's what "looks right" in the industry.
  • The founder's taste. It looks like what the decision-maker personally likes, not what the customer responds to.
  • The trend. It looks current for 18 months and dated after that.

None of these is a design failure. They're strategy failures that show up in the design.

What should come before the visual identity?

The framework we follow is the one marketing professor Mark Ritson teaches in his Mini MBA in Marketing and his columns for Marketing Week. It splits marketing into three stages, in a fixed order:

  1. Diagnosis. Understand the market before changing anything.
  2. Strategy. Decide who you're for and what you stand for.
  3. Tactics. Only then: product, price, channels, communication and design.

The idea isn't new. Ritson's contribution is insisting on the order, and pointing out how often the industry skips straight to step three.

1. Diagnosis: find out what's actually going on

Diagnosis is research. It covers who buys in the category and why, how the brand is seen today (if at all), what competitors own in people's minds, and where the commercial opportunity really is.

Ritson's warning here is simple: you are not your customer. Founders and marketing teams know their product too well to see it the way a buyer does. Assumptions have to be tested, through customer interviews, sales data, search behaviour and competitor audits.

At Blue BearX, diagnosis means talking to people, through customer interviews and surveys, alongside a competitor audit and a review of the client's existing materials. Together with the strategy work, it usually takes two to four weeks.

2. Strategy: choose who you're for and what you stand for

Strategy turns the diagnosis into decisions:

  • Segmentation. How does the market naturally divide? Not just by age or income, but by what different groups need and how they behave.
  • Targeting. Which of those groups will you focus on? This is the hardest step, because it means choosing not to prioritise everyone else.
  • Positioning. What few things should your target customers think of when they think of you? Ritson argues this should fit in a handful of words, not a mission statement.
  • Objectives. What will success look like, in numbers, and by when?

Each of these gets its own article in this series. For now, the key point is that every one of them changes the design brief. A brand aimed at first-time buyers needs different signals from one aimed at experts. A brand positioned on speed should look and move differently from one positioned on craft.

3. Tactics: now design has something to express

This is where the visual identity lives. Design here has a clear job: make the positioning instantly recognisable to the target audience, and build what researchers call distinctive brand assets. These are the colours, shapes, characters and sounds that people link to your brand without reading the name.

That's a much better brief than "make it look premium". It also makes design decisions easier to judge. You're no longer asking "do we like it?" but "does it say what we decided to say, to the people we decided to reach?"

Doesn't strategy slow the project down?

It takes more time at the start, and saves much more time later.

Without a strategy, design reviews turn into opinion contests. Every stakeholder brings their own idea of what the brand should be, because nobody agreed on it first. Rounds of revisions pile up, and the final result is usually a compromise.

With a strategy, the brief settles the arguments before they start. In our experience, it saves far more time than it costs. Design reviews get shorter and revision rounds stop going in circles, because everyone is judging the work against the same brief.

What if we already have a logo we like?

Good. Strategy doesn't mean throwing everything away.

Often the diagnosis shows the existing identity has real value: people recognise it, and that recognition took years to build. In that case the job is to keep what works and fix what doesn't. Ritson often makes this point about brands that rebranded and lost recognition they'd spent decades building.

The strategy tells you which assets to protect and which to change. Without it, you're guessing about that too.

The short version

  • The logo is the last decision, not the first.
  • Diagnosis tells you what's actually going on.
  • Strategy (segmentation, targeting, positioning and objectives) decides who you're for and what you stand for.
  • Design then has a clear job: to express that strategy and make it recognisable.

In Part 2 we'll look at the step most brands skip entirely: diagnosis, and how to research a market properly before making a single decision.


Blue BearX is a boutique brand studio that does the thinking first and the work second. If you're planning a rebrand and want to start in the right place, brief us.


FAQ

What is the right order for building a brand? Research the market first (diagnosis), then decide your target audience and positioning (strategy), and only then design the identity and communication (tactics).

Why shouldn't you start a rebrand with the logo? Because a logo can only express decisions that have already been made. Without a strategy, the design ends up following competitors, the founder's personal taste or a passing trend, not what the target customer needs to see.

Who is Mark Ritson? Mark Ritson is a former marketing professor, a columnist for Marketing Week and the founder of the Mini MBA in Marketing. He's known for teaching the "diagnosis, strategy, tactics" order and for arguing that marketers should research their market before making decisions.

How long does brand strategy take before design starts? At Blue BearX, diagnosis and strategy usually take two to four weeks before design starts.

More Insights