Strategy

Targeting: Why Choosing Fewer Customers Wins More

Short answer: Targeting means choosing which customer segments your brand will focus on, usually one to three, and accepting that you won't prioritise the rest. You choose by asking two questions about each segment: how attractive is it (size, value, growth), and how well can we win it (fit with what we're good at, and the competition). Targeting decides who the brand is designed for. It doesn't stop other people from buying.


This is Part 4 of our series on what should happen before anyone designs a logo. So far: - Part 1: the order (diagnosis, strategy, tactics) - Part 2: diagnosis, the research - Part 3: segmentation, how the market divides

Segmentation described the market. Targeting is the first real decision, and it's the hardest one in the whole process.

Why is targeting so hard?

Because it means saying no.

After segmentation you're looking at a map of, say, five customer groups. Every one of them buys in your category. Every one of them is revenue. Choosing two means deliberately not prioritising the other three, and that feels like walking away from money.

So most companies don't choose. They say "we're for everyone" or "all of these are our customers". Then they write messaging general enough to fit all five groups, and design an identity neutral enough not to put anyone off.

The result is a brand that doesn't really speak to anyone. Mark Ritson makes this point often: the purpose of targeting is to focus, and a strategy that targets everyone isn't a strategy.

We've seen this first-hand. One client was trying to reach as many people as possible. When they focused on a better-fitting audience instead, their sales grew by 23%.

How do you choose which segments to target?

Score each segment on two questions.

Question 1: How attractive is this segment?

  • Size. How many customers are in it?
  • Value. How much do they spend, and how profitable are they?
  • Growth. Is the segment growing or shrinking?
  • Loyalty. Once won, do they stay?

Question 2: How well can we win it?

  • Fit. Does what we offer actually match what this segment needs most?
  • Strengths. Do we have an advantage they'd care about, like product, price, expertise or reputation?
  • Competition. Is someone else already strongly established here?
  • Reach. Can we reach these people affordably?

Put the segments on a simple grid:

Hard to winEasy to win
AttractiveLong-term goal: worth building towardsTarget first
Less attractiveAvoidSecondary target, or serve without focusing on

The segments in the top right (attractive and winnable) are your primary targets. That sounds obvious, but the diagnosis from Part 2 is what makes it honest. Without research, every team believes they can win every segment.

We keep the decision small: usually four to six people, each with a job. The decision owner (founder or CEO), the person who owns revenue, someone who talks to customers every week, whoever holds the budget, and the brand or marketing lead. We facilitate, bring the research and push back on assumptions, but we don't vote. Anyone who would only react to the outcome stays out. A crowded room produces a target list of "everyone".

Before the session, each person sends their top three audiences with one piece of evidence for each, so the loudest voice doesn't win. In the session we score each audience on fit, ability to pay, ease of reach and growth potential, and agree one primary and one secondary target. At the end, the decision owner states the choice out loud and signs it off, and we record what was ruled out and why.

How many segments should you target?

Usually one to three.

  • One primary target. The segment the brand is built around. Its needs shape the positioning, the message and the visual identity.
  • One or two secondary targets (optional). These are segments you'll also serve, but without designing the brand around them.

More than three, and you're back to "everyone". Each extra segment pulls the brand in a different direction, and the positioning gets vaguer.

Continuing the example

Illustrative, not a real client.

In Part 3 we split a small-business software market into four segments: the overwhelmed founder, the process builder, the reluctant team and the price shopper.

Scoring them:

SegmentAttractive?Can we win it?Decision
Overwhelmed founderLarge, willing to pay for simplicityOur product is the fastest to set upPrimary target
Process builderValuable, but demandingCompetitors have deeper featuresLong-term, not now
Reluctant teamLarge, but they don't choose the toolThey follow the founder's choiceSecondary: won through the founder
Price shopperLow value, low loyaltyNot a fight worth havingDon't focus on

Now look at what that decision does to the brand. Built for the overwhelmed founder, everything gets simpler: "Set up in an afternoon" becomes the message. The identity should feel calm, clear and quick, not technical and feature-heavy. That one choice settles dozens of later debates about copy and design.

Doesn't targeting mean losing everyone else?

No, and this is the most common misunderstanding.

Targeting decides who the brand is designed for. It doesn't decide who's allowed to buy. People outside your target will still buy from you, often because a clear brand is more attractive to everyone than a vague one.

Ritson's "bothism" (from Part 3) applies here too. Choose a target to shape the brand, but don't shrink your media to just that target. Research on how brands grow, especially from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, suggests that reaching the wider category matters a lot for growth. So:

  • Strategy is targeted: positioning, product decisions, design.
  • Reach can be broad: advertising and visibility across the whole category.

These two work together, not against each other.

What's the difference between a target market and a target audience?

They're often used to mean the same thing, but it helps to keep them apart:

  • Target market (or target segment): the group of customers your brand strategy is built for. That's this article.
  • Target audience: the people a specific campaign or ad is aimed at. It can be broader or narrower depending on the job of that campaign.

Mixing these up is how brands end up with a strategy built around whoever the last campaign targeted.

The short version

  • Targeting is a decision, and it means saying no.
  • Score each segment on how attractive it is and how well you can win it.
  • Target one to three segments: one primary, and up to two secondary.
  • The primary target shapes everything after it: positioning, message and design.
  • Targeting isn't exclusion. Others can still buy, and your advertising can still reach broadly.

In Part 5 we'll decide what the brand should stand for in the minds of the people we've chosen: positioning, in a handful of words.


Blue BearX is a boutique brand studio that does the thinking first and the work second. Trying to be everything to everyone? Brief us.


FAQ

What is targeting in marketing? Targeting is choosing which customer segments a brand will focus on, after the market has been segmented. It decides who the brand's positioning, product and design are built around.

How do you choose a target market? Score each segment on two things: how attractive it is (size, value, growth and loyalty) and how well your company can win it (fit, strengths, competition and reach). Focus on segments that score well on both.

How many target markets should a brand have? Usually one primary target and up to two secondary ones. Targeting more than three segments tends to make the positioning vague.

Does targeting mean you ignore other customers? No. Targeting decides who the brand is designed for, not who can buy. Many brands target a focused segment but still advertise broadly across the category.

What is the difference between a target market and a target audience? A target market is the customer segment the brand strategy is built for. A target audience is the group a specific campaign or ad is aimed at, which can be broader or narrower.

More Insights